Although annuities and investments are not the same things, there are important differences and similarities between them:
Other than variable annuities, 100% of the principal and the growth of an annuity is guaranteed, no matter what. Even when the stock market was down 40% in 2007 and 35% in 2020, annuity contracts were protected and no principal was lost. With variable annuities, the policyowner does assume market risk, making them very different tools. What follows is a discussion of some of the pros and cons of annuities versus investments.
Annuities create GUARANTEED, INCOME FOR LIFE. Using the right annuities can create unbeatable amounts guaranteed, future income that will be greater than any other strategy. For this reason, many people describe annuities as private pension plans.
All the money in an annuity is guaranteed, including all gains it earns from the day it is purchased. Everything in an annuity contract is regulated and spelled out, providing the most transparency. This creates safety, security and predictable outcomes. This is quite different from investments, such as real estate or equities in the stock market, which are good examples of speculation and risk. One is not better or worse than the other. They all have their places in a comprehensive financial plan. Annuities are precise, transparent and dependable. Most of our clients have annuities and investments.
Tax Deferral: Not paying tax during the annuity’s growth phase can be very meaningful. Taxes will ultimately be paid on distributions. Annuities are not tax shelters but the advantages of tax deferral is significant, especially for retirement purposes.
Rather than exposing inherited assets to loss, mismanagement and other risks, annuities are often used to create lifetime income for beneficiaries. Grandparents are increasingly using annuities to create sheltered income for children and grandchildren. Structured properly, the income is protected and safe from divorce and probate.
Unlike investments, some annuity companies offer generous bonuses to new policyholders. They do this by crediting the incoming account value with as much as 10%. Many people consider the bonus as an offset to surrender charges. The bonuses are added to the annuity’s account value and begin earning interest from day one.
Most annuities have NO FEES and there is NO COMMISSION paid from your assets. The one time commission is paid from the insurance company, NOT YOUR ASSETS. For example, when you pay a single premium of $200,000 into an annuity, the amount earning interest from day one is $200,000 plus the bonus if there is one. In comparison, a 1% fee for the same $200,000 investment is reducing the account value each year, by $2000. At the end of 10 years, it adds up to $20,000. If that fee taken from your account is 1.5%, then you will pay $30,000 over 10 years.
For people under age 59.5, there is a small penalty for withdrawing money from their annuity. Investments are not subject to these types of penalties.
Some annuities and some investments have surrender penalties. CDs are examples of investments with surrender penalties. Annuities have small, declining surrender penalties to allow insurance companies to invest your money with longer durations and better returns.
For a quote, please call us at 561-771-4647 or email Ted Bernstein, about a complimentary phone consultation.
The purpose of an IRA is to create future, guaranteed income in retirement. Investing your IRA assets into an income annuity creates the most guaranteed lifetime income, WITHOUT PRINCIPAL RISK.
IRA assets are being transferred from risky equities to guaranteed income annuities, in record numbers. These annuities are contracts that guarantee the principal will never be lost in down markets and they guarantee income that is payable for life.
Most of the people we speak with are more interested in being invested in the right strategy that guarantees maximum future income without risking principal. Billions of dollars every year are being moved out of brokerage firms and into annuity contracts because a diversified portfolio of equities leaves your retirement assets exposed to risk. As a result, these brokerage and wealth management firms respond with aggressive campaigns designed to discredit annuities. One brokerage firm, Ken Fisher, rails against annuities as their main marketing campaign.
Income Annuities Are Right For IRA Assets.
You are required to take annual distributions from your IRA at age 72. These income payments are pre-determined by IRS guidelines, known as Required Minimum Distributions, and the IRS does not require that your distributions must be payable for life. That responsibility falls on the IRA owner. Even though most people WANT guaranteed lifetime income from their IRA, most are not invested for that outcome. Most people have their IRA assets invested in a high percentage of equities.
A simple comparison tells the story.
Assume that two 65 year olds have identical IRAs, currently worth $500,000. The primary goal at retirement is to provide guaranteed income for life. At 72, they must begin taking income payments (RMDs). The two IRAs are identical except for how the $500,000 is invested in each.
Traditional IRA #1 is invested in diversified securities.
IRA #2 is invested in a guaranteed, income annuity that will pay income FOR LIFE. It can NEVER LOSE PRINCIPAL and the INCOME is contractually guaranteed. It will share in market gains when the markets are up.
ANNUITY + IRA = PEANUT BUTTER & CHOCOLATE
The IRA with the income annuity is better because it provides the HIGHEST GUARANTEED PAYMENTS FOR LIFE, without assuming any risk. The IRA with diversified securities can lose principal at any time. Losses are devastating in retirement considering that there is no future income to offset them.
If you agree that important goals in retirement are to preserve principal and make sure you don’t outlive your money, then Few things create guaranteed lifetime income like an annuity. Some critics say the tax deferred status of an annuity is wasted inside an IRA but this is not so. It is a classic red-herring argument designed to confuse people. The IRA’s primary objective is to create maximum retirement income for retirement and the indexed annuity does exactly that.
If you are unfamiliar with how these special annuities strengthen your IRA distributions, I offer a complimentary discussion to help give you a better understanding of these vehicles.
Economists and professors from Harvard, Wharton, Duke and Stanford all agree about the undisputed advantages and benefits of indexed annuities.
Says Michael Kitces, investment planning expert: “Given these changes, it is perhaps time to abolish the ‘annuities should never go into an IRA’ rule and recognize that it has become more a myth and remnant of old than proper advice in today’s environment.”
“You have asked an excellent question. Thank you for asking. The Stock Market is in a Bear Market even though the Financial Services Industry would prefer that the average American not know this reality.
Below is a chart of the S&P500 which is an index of the largest and most important corporations in the US. There are actually 505 companies issues in this index. It is formulated and averaged so it is not the total price of all of these but a value based on this quantitative formula. This is a Monthly Chart so that you can see that this is indeed a Bear Market and that is is just beginning. The monthly chart provides enough data so that you can see the prior two most recent Bear Markets also. The Bear of 2000–2003 and the Bear of 2007–2009. And at the far right hand side, the current bear of 2020 -______.
There were also the SARS epidemic of 2002, and the H1N1 Flu Pandemic of 2009. So all 3 Bears had either had a serious new novel virus develop at some point in the bear cycle. Now, please remember that technical analysis is NOT a predictive tool. It is a graphical tool that uses historical data to study prior market activity to understand the current situation. Every Bear Market is unique but every bear market has similarities to past bear markets. Studying 120 years of bear markets, the average bear loss is 50%. The duration is average 1.9 years depending on the speed of the loss. Slower bear declines last longer, fast steep bears are shorter in duration.
The Stock Market LEADS the economy. In other words, the stock market reflects the corporate and business health at growth potential BEFORE the economy goes into a recession AND before the economy begins to recover and later expand. Studying the history of the past two bears we can see that the stock market recovered well ahead of the economy. The recessions lasted longer but the stock market was already bottoming and moving upward as the recessions continued. It is common for Bear Markets to have 3 phases: Denial, Disbelief, and Capitulation. The recent rebound occurred (indexes and components moving up) occurred precisely at a strong technical support level. Technical indicators signaled early that a rebound aka fake rally was likely as the indexes hit that support level.
Banks acting as Market Makers supported the major index components which are heavily weighted to specific corporations deemed most important to the economy by the banks, financial industry and government. Then the Financial Services Industry, needing inflows of money to stay in business launched a massive promotion to new investors and inexperienced investors telling them that the recent market crash was an “opportunity to buy stocks at bargain prices!”
So many younger investors, or new investors who know nothing about how all of this works as the educational system in the US doesn’t provide education about the financial markets even for college students unless their degree is in financial services. Many new franchises also started recently from the popular neighborhood broker franchises. You see them in the strip malls. These smaller funds managers are new too and trust their corporate statements which tell them how to promote to get more money to place to stay in business. There has been a massive amount of money taken out of the stock market over the past 2 years. Money Market Funds are holding a vast quantity of funds in safety while this bear is still going on. These are the wise, experienced, educated investors who wisely sold during the speculative activity in 2019 to January 2020. The first quarter earnings season starts April 14th. The professional side of the market knows that the earnings reports are going to be the worst since 2008–2009, perhaps worse.
The recent runs up are technically very fragile. There is no longer billions of corporate cash to continue buybacks which fueled the 2018 -2020 speculative bubble. Therefore, this bear market is just on pause for the moment. The market is not in a rally. Stocks are not near their previous all time highs. This is just a bear market bounce. These happen periodically during a bear and mislead the average investor into buying stocks into a bear market…” April 24th, 2020
We all wish we could make money when the markets are up and avoid losing it when markets are down. Conservative and aggressive investors alike – nobody wants losses!
As investors, we want the best of both worlds. When markets are up, we want to stay invested with minimal risk and we want to protect our gains. It is tempting to let it ride just a little longer and to stay fully invested, often against our own, best judgment. The problem is that markets take sudden turns for the worse. When they do, it can be paralyzing and difficult to minimize losses or to get out at the right time. It is difficult to consider changing course during these times and it is equally difficult to watch your assets plunging. With retirement assets, a sudden move down can be very costly. Waiting for the markets to cycle back up again is a completely different experience at age 67 than it is at 45. Time is not on your side. Depending on the severity of the drop and its duration will determine the extent of your losses.
The Good news.
The best time to consider alternatives is at the top of a market cycle. Instead of being too heavily invested in equities that offer no protection, a balance of income generating assets and equities will better protect your retirement assets. Income generating annuities are state-of-the-art, with indexes that participate in rising markets. Since they are not investments, there is no investment risk. Your principal and any growth is always guaranteed. While there is nothing inherently wrong with risky investments; they should not be the foundation of a retirement plan.
What I am asking you to consider are guaranteed income contracts or Fixed Indexed Annuities. Think of them as marketindexed annuities because returns are partially based on how markets perform, without every being exposed to market losses.
“ROI is Reliability of Income in retirement, not Return on Investment. The goal of retirement security is achieved through a shift in focus from asset accumulation to income and asset protection.
Annuities are over 200 years old. THERE IS NO LOSS OF PRINCIPAL which is the PRIMARY ATTRACTION of an indexed annuity. During the 2008 Financial Crisis and the Covid bear market drop, none of our clients lost a dollar in their fixed indexed annuities. Today, there are millions of indexed annuities inside IRAs and other retirement plans. People want gains when the markets are rising and they want guaranteed income for life with downside risk.
The world’s leading economists all agree about the value of annuities in retirement. Consider what they say because they are unbiased and impartial. It makes no difference to them whether we invest our retirement assets in hedge funds or annuities. When Olivia Mitchell from Wharton (check out her incredible resume) says that annuities are key assets to own in retirement, she is saying so because she’s spent her entire career studying these issues. Nobody explains why mortality credits are the most valuable asset in annuities, better than Tom Hegna. When Professor Wade Pfau at The American College, or Roger Ibbotson from Yale write books about the advantages of annuities, their pro-annuity positions are credible because they don’t sell products.
Professor Pfau stresses that “investors typically fall into the ‘trap’ of depending on investment portfolios as the chief way to fund their retirement. Now, many of these folks in retirement find themselves needing a life raft…acquiring an annuity would have prevented such a dire scenario“, he argues.
HOW CAN YOU DO THIS?
Theseannuities are designed to modestly beat the performance of other fixed income products and typically, they do just that. There are also times when they do much better. These are important years that can really boost the overall performance of an annuity. For example, many of our clients earned as much as 14% from January, 2019 to January, 2020. Those were extraordinary returns because the market was experiencing extraordinary growth during that same period.
More Good News: The gains credited to an annuity contract can never be lost. The upside potential of an indexed annuity is determined by a contract, offering an additional level of security.
Personally, I do not like to hype the upside of market indexed annuitiesbecause their other advantages can be just as powerful.
Let no one with a financial interest in your assets dissuade you from making a financially sound and prudent decision, especially one that may be in your best interest. When you move money away from stock brokerage firms or wealth management firms, they’re losing significant, recurring revenue that is earned from your assets. I have no problem with fees charged by professionals. But, it should come as NO SURPRISE if they make you second guess a decision to move your assets away from their firm. To keep this simple, if you pay an annual fee of 1.5% on $1,000,000 of assets, that is $15,000 per year, or $150,000 of your money over 10 years.
When markets tumble and the assets in your account go down, so too does the revenue for the investment firm and the investment manager that is managing your money. Can you trust the advice of an advisor who loses annual income if you liquidate or move your account? Is that structure in your best interest? Most investors are not aware of these potential conflicts and many are surprised when they finally understand them.
Who doesn’t want more guaranteed, lifetime income? These annuities pay you for as long as you live AND guarantee the principal – forever. If the market drops 30%, you lose nothing. If you want certainty, predictable outcomes and no anxiety over your retirement security, this is for you.
“You pay no commission from your annuity assets. Instead of paying “forever fees” in managed accounts, fees that are directly reducing your retirement fund each year, there are no annual annuity fees*. The one-time commission is paid from the assets of the insurance company, NEVER FROM YOUR ASSETS! The interest calculations, participation rates and the contract terms are regulated by the Department of Insurance in your state.”
*Some people choose riders that may have annual, disclosed fees.
Guaranteed annuities are ideal for those of us who cannot stomach market volatility or wondering when the next crash will begin. Many people cannot tolerate watching their retirement assets evaporate during these market events. Hearing an advisor tell you “not to panic” or “it always comes back, be patient”, doesn’t help. That’s never easy to hear. In, or near retirement, you must be aware of a risk called “sequence of returns risk”. If markets are down near the beginning of your retirement, down years can be far more damaging. If you are drawing money from your retirement assets, down years can be more damaging.
From 2000 to 2020, there have been three major bear markets and if you owned an indexed annuity, you avoided all three. That’s “peace of mind” – not a dollar lost over 20 years. Market indexed annuities are only available from major insurance companies because only these insurance companies are financially strong enough to provide the guarantees. They prove their financial strength to regulators and rating agencies each year.
The numbers say it all. In the chart below, the market-indexed annuity has performed nearly as well as the S&P 500 total return index (including dividends). WITH NO RISK!
Are annuities safe? If you are a conservative to moderate investor, why not let a market-indexed annuity take some of the most important guesswork out of your retirement planning? When the indexes are up, you can make money. If markets crash or if volatility takes over, you will never lose money. Keeping this simple, if you had put $500,000 in an indexed annuity in January or February of 2020, you still have $500,000 of principal today, plus possible gains. Your principal is always intact — always at the highest level it reached, which is called the high water mark.
You want the best of all possible worlds.
How Does This Work? Since the insurance company guarantees the principal, they share in some of the upside, when the markets are up.
“Don’t compare annuities to what might have been if interest rates had been higher, compare them to what is possible and available now. Now we are stuck with low rates. Trying to wait for rates to increase is going to eat away at your assets in the meantime, and there is nothing you can really gain from the effort. Low interest rates strengthen, not weaken, the case for purchasing a single premium immediate annuity.” Wade Pfau
Ken Fisher hates annuities.Why do some financial “experts” criticize annuities? Everytime a Ken Fisher client liquidates and moves money to an insurance company for the purchase of an annuity, Ken Fisher’s firm loses annual recurring revenue. Maybe this is why Ken Fisher hates annuities?
Which Is The Best Indexed Annuity?
There are thousands of annuities in the market. It is our job to know them and to know which one suits you best. To do that, we listen to what you expect in order to meet your goals and objectives. Some contracts are too expensive and some carry hidden fees and charges. You want to make sure to buy the right indexed annuity from an experienced professional who only represents insurance companies with high ratings.
Ready to start protecting your retirement assets and never lose money in the market again?
Contact us and allow us to answer all your questions? You have nothing to lose by taking a complimentary phone call. Time does matter. A low interest rate environment forces insurance companies to lower the rates for new clients. Safety is what drives their investment decisions and in order to properly respond to lower interest rates, they will change their offers accordingly.
Start the ball rolling and call us or fill out the simple contact form on this page or any page of the this site. We can be reached at 561-771-4647
